Skip to main content

Appalachian Today

News and events at Appalachian State University
  • Subscribe
  • For the media
  • Contact
  • Events
  • Webcams
  • Podcasts
  • In the News
  • Research & Arts
  • Awards
  • Experts
  • All News
  • Topics
  • Accolades
  • Alumni
  • Arts and Humanities
  • Athletics
  • Awards and Honors
  • Community Engagement
  • Diversity
  • Events
  • Faculty and Staff
  • Gifts and Grants
  • Global
  • Health and Wellness
  • Publications
  • Research and Creative Works
  • Safety
  • Scholarships
  • Students
  • Sustainability
☰ Menu
  • Events
  • Webcams
  • Podcasts
  • In the News
  • Research & Arts
  • Awards
  • Experts
  • All News
  • Topics
  • Subscribe
  • For the media
  • Contact

Certain moral values may lead to more prejudice and discrimination, study finds

Appalachian social psychologist Dr. Andrew Monroe studies relationship between moral values and prejudice

View larger image

Social psychologist Dr. Andrew Monroe, leading a class at Appalachian State University. Photo by Marie Freeman

“How do we morally communicate? It can be in very different ways because we speak different moral languages. People’s understanding of facts differ based on their moral values.”

Dr. Andrew Monroe, Department of Psychology

Undergraduate students involved in this research
  • Morgan Coyle, a senior psychology major from Cary.
  • Amanda Pinto, a senior psychology major from Charlotte.
  • Lyndsey Porter, a senior psychology major from Alpharetta, Georgia.
  • Rebecca Smith, a senior psychology major from Waxhaw.
  • Jeané Ridges, a senior psychology major from Wake Forest.
  • John Dwiggins, a senior psychology major from Charlotte.
  • Dominic Ysidron ’18, a psychology and philosophy double major now in graduate school at Ohio University.
News Media Attention

These outlets have carried news of Dr. Andrew Monroe’s study:

  • Valuing Moral Law Over Compassion May Lead to Prejudice
    Psych Central
  • Certain moral values may lead to more prejudice, discrimination
    Medical Xpress
By Kaitlin Luna, American Psychological Association News, and Linda Coutant, University Communications
Posted Jan. 15, 2019 at 9:45 a.m.

BOONE, N.C. — People who value following purity rules over caring for others are more likely to view gay and transgender people as less human, which motivates prejudicial feelings and support for discriminatory public policies, according to a new study published by the American Psychological Association.

Dr. Andrew Monroe, an assistant professor in Appalachian State University’s Dr. Wiley F. Smith Department of Psychology, is the lead author of “The Dark Side of Morality: Prioritizing Sanctity Over Care Motivates Denial of Mind and Prejudice Toward Sexual Outgroups,” published Dec. 20, 2018, in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General.

“How do we morally communicate? It can be in very different ways because we speak different moral languages. People’s understanding of facts differ based on their moral values.”

Dr. Andrew Monroe, Department of Psychology

“After the Supreme Court decision affirming marriage equality and the debate over bathroom rights for transgender people, we realized that the arguments were often not about facts but about opposing moral beliefs,” Monroe said. “Thus, we wanted to understand if moral values were an underlying cause of prejudice toward gay and transgender people.”

Monroe and his co-author, social psychologist Dr. Ashby Plant, of Florida State University, focused on two specific moral values: what they called sanctity, a strict adherence to purity rules and disgust over acts that are considered morally contaminating; and care, which centers on the disapproval of others who cause suffering without just cause. They predicted those values might be behind the often-heated debates over LGBTQ rights.

The researchers conducted five experiments, with nearly 1,100 participants, examining the relationship between moral values and prejudice. Overall, they found that people who prioritized sanctity over care were more likely to believe that gay and transgender people, people with AIDS and prostitutes were more impulsive, less rational and, therefore, something less than human. These attitudes increased prejudice and acceptance of discriminatory public policies, according to Monroe.

Conversely, people who endorsed care over sanctity were more likely to show compassion for those populations, as well as support public policies that would help, the researchers found.

“The belief that a person is no better than an animal can become a justification for tolerating and causing harm,” Plant said. “When we believe that someone lacks self-control and discipline, we may make moral judgments about their life choices and behaviors, which can lead down a dark path of discrimination and hate.”

Possible implications

Research into LGBTQ prejudice is relevant, Monroe said, citing North Carolina’s loss of revenue as a result of its 2016 House Bill 2, which placed restrictions on restroom use by transgender individuals, and the Trump administration’s seeking of a ban on transgender military service.

Monroe said the first step to curing prejudice is to understand how it functions. Therefore, a possible implication of these findings, he said, is that understanding a root cause of prejudice can lead to ways to address prejudice.

“Our study suggests that a person’s moral values can be altered, at least temporarily, and that highlighting certain values, like caring, can be an effective way to combat prejudice,” he said.

Participants exhibited this shift in the final experiment, during which their care values were primed by researchers through a radio news clip on the importance of safe spaces for people of color, while in the control condition, participants listened to a clip about Brexit.

“We hope that by showing the moral roots of bias and discrimination against sexual and gender minorities we encourage others to conduct further research to increase equity and inclusion,” Monroe said.

Applying moral differences to other issues

The authors’ research into moral values can be a framework to explain other phenomena, according to Monroe.

In a similar study underway at Appalachian, Monroe is exploring how differing moral values are at play in debates regarding NFL players taking a knee during the playing of the national anthem.

“Likewise, we’re finding people who value respect for authority over fairness get upset and describe the players as ‘ungrateful’ and ‘disrespectful’ while those who value fairness more than respect for authority view the players’ protests as meaningful,” he said.

Understanding differences in moral values might help people have more constructive conversations about these and other challenging issues, Monroe said.

“How do we morally communicate? It can be in very different ways because we speak different moral languages. People’s understanding of facts differ based on their moral values.”

Undergraduate students involved in this research
  • Morgan Coyle, a senior psychology major from Cary.
  • Amanda Pinto, a senior psychology major from Charlotte.
  • Lyndsey Porter, a senior psychology major from Alpharetta, Georgia.
  • Rebecca Smith, a senior psychology major from Waxhaw.
  • Jeané Ridges, a senior psychology major from Wake Forest.
  • John Dwiggins, a senior psychology major from Charlotte.
  • Dominic Ysidron ’18, a psychology and philosophy double major now in graduate school at Ohio University.
News Media Attention

These outlets have carried news of Dr. Andrew Monroe’s study:

  • Valuing Moral Law Over Compassion May Lead to Prejudice
    Psych Central
  • Certain moral values may lead to more prejudice, discrimination
    Medical Xpress
Thinking about your future may make you less trusting and more critical of others
Thinking about your future may make you less trusting and more critical of others
March 21, 2017

Appalachian State University’s Dr. Andrew Monroe is a psychologist in the College of Arts and Sciences who studies people’s moral and social judgments.

Read the story
Psychology Alumnus Dominic Ysidron and Dr. Andrew Monroe Present at International Conference on Replication in Science
Psychology Alumnus Dominic Ysidron and Dr. Andrew Monroe Present at International Conference on Replication in Science
Department of Psychology
June 19, 2018

Dominic Ysidron '18 and Dr. Andrew Monroe presented their recent research on free will and morality at the 9th Annual International Conference on Reproducibility and Replicability in Psychology and Experimental Philosophy at University College London, UK.

Read the story

About the Dr. Wiley F. Smith Department of Psychology

Appalachian State University’s Dr. Wiley F. Smith Department of Psychology serves more than 1,400 undergraduate majors seeking the Bachelor of Arts or Bachelor of Science degree in psychology, as well as 90 graduate students across four graduate programs: experimental psychology (MA), industrial-organizational psychology and human resource management (MA), school psychology (MA/SSP) and clinical psychology (PsyD). Learn more at https://psych.appstate.edu.

About the College of Arts and Sciences

The College of Arts and Sciences (CAS) at Appalachian State University is home to 17 academic departments, two centers and one residential college. These units span the humanities and the social, mathematical and natural sciences. CAS aims to develop a distinctive identity built upon our university's strengths, traditions and locations. The college’s values lie not only in service to the university and local community, but through inspiring, training, educating and sustaining the development of its students as global citizens. More than 6,800 student majors are enrolled in the college. As the college is also largely responsible for implementing App State’s general education curriculum, it is heavily involved in the education of all students at the university, including those pursuing majors in other colleges. Learn more at https://cas.appstate.edu.

About Appalachian State University

As a premier public institution, Appalachian State University prepares students to lead purposeful lives. App State is one of 17 campuses in the University of North Carolina System, with a national reputation for innovative teaching and opening access to a high-quality, affordable education for all. The university enrolls more than 21,000 students, has a low student-to-faculty ratio and offers more than 150 undergraduate and 80 graduate majors at its Boone and Hickory campuses and through App State Online. Learn more at https://www.appstate.edu.

What do you think?

Share your feedback on this story.

Share

Topics

  • Diversity
  • Faculty and Staff
  • Research and Creative Works

What do you think?

Share your feedback on this story.

Archives

Appalachian Today is an online publication of Appalachian State University. This website consolidates university news, feature stories, events, photo galleries, videos and podcasts.

If you cannot find what you're looking for here, please refer to the following sources:

  • Podcasts may be found at Appalachian State University Podcasts
  • Stories and press releases published prior to Jan. 1, 2015 may be found in University Communications Records at the Special Collections Research Center.
  • A university-wide Google Calendar may be found at Events at Appalachian

What do you think?

Share your feedback on this story.

Share

Topics

  • Diversity
  • Faculty and Staff
  • Research and Creative Works

Other Recent Posts

  • Student research and creative projects spotlighted at App State’s annual showcase
    Student research and creative projects spotlighted at App State’s annual showcase
  • Will Sears appointed vice chancellor of university advancement at App State
    Will Sears appointed vice chancellor of university advancement at App State
  • N.C. Governor Josh Stein to address graduates at App State commencement
    N.C. Governor Josh Stein to address graduates at App State commencement
  • App State honors 29 students, faculty and staff with 2025 Awards of Distinction
    App State honors 29 students, faculty and staff with 2025 Awards of Distinction
  • App State to offer AI concentration in master’s programs [faculty featured]
    App State to offer AI concentration in master’s programs [faculty featured]
    WFDD
  • Campus emergency siren test to be conducted May 7
    Campus emergency siren test to be conducted May 7
  • App State students help restore national wildlife refuge as part of Alternative Service Experience
    App State students help restore national wildlife refuge as part of Alternative Service Experience
  • Dr. Neva J. Specht appointed App State executive vice chancellor and provost
    Dr. Neva J. Specht appointed App State executive vice chancellor and provost
  • $2 million grant funds scholarships, supports STEM education for over 50 App State students
    $2 million grant funds scholarships, supports STEM education for over 50 App State students
  • App State named Military Friendly School for 16th consecutive year, ranked a top 10 institution for 2025–26
    App State named Military Friendly School for 16th consecutive year, ranked a top 10 institution for 2025–26
  • Explore the future of business with new AI master’s degree tracks at App State
    Explore the future of business with new AI master’s degree tracks at App State
  • 12th annual iBackAPP Day of Giving draws over 3,100 App State supporters worldwide
    12th annual iBackAPP Day of Giving draws over 3,100 App State supporters worldwide

Archives

Appalachian Today is an online publication of Appalachian State University. This website consolidates university news, feature stories, events, photo galleries, videos and podcasts.

If you cannot find what you're looking for here, please refer to the following sources:

  • Podcasts may be found at Appalachian State University Podcasts
  • Stories and press releases published prior to Jan. 1, 2015 may be found in University Communications Records at the Special Collections Research Center.
  • A university-wide Google Calendar may be found at Events at Appalachian
  • Events
  • Videos
  • Galleries
  • In the News
  • Research & Arts
  • Awards
  • Experts
  • All News
  • Topics
  • Subscribe
  • For the media
  • COVID updates
  • Contact

App State

Copyright 2025 Appalachian State University. All rights reserved.

University Communications
ASU Box 32153
Boone, NC 28608
828-262-6156
[email protected]

Abouts

Disclaimer | EO Policy | Accessibility | Website manager: montaldipa (beltmr) .. | Website Feedback

Facebook Twitter YouTube Instagram LinkedIn Snapchat